ServiceNomad RV · Knowledge
Buying a Motorhome vs Travel Trailer
Choosing between a motorhome and a towable RV (travel trailer, fifth wheel) is one of the first big decisions new RV buyers face. Both types have pros and cons, and the best choice depends on your lifestyle, budget, and mechanical comfort level. This guide compares the two from a maintenance and repair perspective, helping you understand what you're signing up for with each option.
Maintenance and Repair Complexity
Motorhomes are self-contained vehicles with an engine, transmission, and all the RV living systems. This means you have two sets of systems to maintain—the chassis (like a truck or van) and the living area (like a house). You'll need to handle engine oil changes, transmission service, brake work, and tire rotations, plus all the RV-specific maintenance like roof sealing, appliance service, and plumbing. If something breaks, you may need to visit multiple shops—a diesel mechanic for the engine and an RV tech for the living systems. Towables, on the other hand, have no engine or transmission, so maintenance is limited to the RV living systems and the tow vehicle (which you probably already own). This can make towables simpler and cheaper to maintain over the long term.
Cost of Ownership and Depreciation
Motorhomes typically cost more upfront and depreciate faster than towables. You're paying for an engine, transmission, and chassis in addition to the living space. Maintenance costs are also higher—motorhome engines and transmissions require regular service, and repairs can be expensive. Towables generally cost less to buy and depreciate more slowly. However, you'll need a capable tow vehicle, which adds to your total investment. If you already own a truck or SUV that can tow, a towable might be the more economical choice. If you don't, you'll need to factor in the cost of buying and maintaining a tow vehicle.
Flexibility and Usability
Motorhomes offer convenience—you can drive directly to your campsite without unhitching, and you can access the living area while traveling (though passengers should remain seated and belted). However, once you're parked, you need the motorhome to run errands or explore, or you'll need to tow a vehicle behind it (a 'toad'). Towables give you the flexibility to unhitch and use your tow vehicle for exploring, but setting up and tearing down camp is more involved. From a maintenance perspective, motorhomes can be harder to work on because the living area is built onto the chassis, making access to some systems more difficult. Towables are often easier to access and repair because everything is more open and modular.
Making the Right Choice for You
If you value convenience, plan to travel frequently, and don't mind the higher maintenance costs, a motorhome might be the right choice. If you prefer flexibility, want to minimize maintenance complexity, and already own a capable tow vehicle, a towable might make more sense. Consider your mechanical skills, comfort with engine work, and budget for ongoing maintenance. Talk to other RV owners and visit dealerships to get a feel for both types. There's no wrong choice—just the choice that fits your lifestyle and expectations.
💡 Prevention Tips
- Consider your mechanical skills and comfort level with engine and transmission maintenance when choosing between a motorhome and a towable.
- Factor in the cost of a tow vehicle if you're considering a towable—it's a significant part of the total investment.
- Talk to other RV owners and ask about their maintenance experiences with motorhomes vs. towables.
- Visit dealerships and inspect both types to see which layout and maintenance approach appeals to you.
- Budget for ongoing maintenance and repairs—both types require regular upkeep, but motorhomes typically cost more.
Can't fix it yourself?
Don't let a mechanical issue ruin your trip. Connect with vetted mobile RV technicians who can come to your location and get you back on the road.